My very first summer I tried both versions of A Tale of Two Strawberry Pies and fell in love with the contrast: one bright, glossy classic strawberry pie with a tabletopping glaze, and a cool, creamy strawberry cream pie that slices like silk. This recipe is perfect when strawberries are at their peak and you want two very different textures on the same table: one for people who crave fruit-forward brightness and one for those who prefer a soft, custardy finish. If you need a dessert that pleases a crowd after a quick family meal, it pairs wonderfully with a hearty weeknight option like 30-minute ground beef stroganoff for a full, satisfying menu.

Why you’ll love this dish

These are not two small variations of the same pie. One pie celebrates the strawberries in a simple, glazed filling that shows off their shape and flavor. The other suspends chopped berries in lightly sweetened cream, offering a cool contrast that keeps well on a warm day. Both pies are approachable enough for confident beginners, but they also let you use pro techniques—like macerating fruit and adjusting thickening agents—to dial in texture.

"I made both pies for a family gathering and everyone fought over the last slice. The glazed pie looked like a magazine cover and the cream pie vanished first."

Both pies work for potlucks, summer picnics, or a special weekend brunch. The glazed version ships well in a pie carrier. The cream version benefits from being made the day before, which makes hosting easier.

Step-by-step overview

Quick overview so you know what to expect: prepare two pie crusts (homemade or store-bought), macerate strawberries for the glazed pie and make a cornstarch-thickened glaze, and prepare a chilled custard base for the cream pie that gets folded with whipped cream and fresh berries. One pie bakes for a short time to set the crust; the cream pie is assembled cold and chilled to firm up. Total active time is about 45 to 60 minutes, plus chilling.

What you’ll need

Glazed Strawberry Pie (Pie A)

• 1 9-inch pie crust, blind-baked or unbaked depending on preference
• 1 1/2 pounds fresh strawberries, hulled and halved
• 3/4 cup granulated sugar
• 2 tablespoons cornstarch
• 1/2 cup water
• 1 tablespoon lemon juice
• 1 tablespoon unsalted butter (optional, for gloss)
• Pinch of salt

Strawberry Cream Pie (Pie B)

• 1 9-inch pre-baked pie crust (graham cracker or shortcrust)
• 8 ounces cream cheese, room temperature
• 1/2 cup powdered sugar
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1 cup heavy cream, cold
• 1 cup chopped fresh strawberries
• Zest of half a lemon (optional, brightens flavor)

Pan and equipment

• 9-inch pie pans (two)
• Saucepan, whisk, mixing bowls, electric mixer, spatula

Notes on substitutions

• Cornstarch can be swapped for arrowroot at a 1:1 ratio for the glaze.
• Use a gluten-free crust to adapt the pies for gluten-free diets.
• If strawberries are very sweet, reduce sugar in fillings by 1 to 2 tablespoons.

How to prepare it

1. Preheat oven to 400 F for blind baking a crust if using unbaked pie shells. Blind bake crusts with pie weights for about 12 minutes until edges are lightly golden. Cool before filling.
2. For the glazed pie: toss halved strawberries with 2 tablespoons sugar and let sit for 15 minutes to macerate. Heat water, remaining sugar, cornstarch, and salt in a small saucepan. Whisk until thick and glossy, then stir in lemon juice and butter. Fold in macerated strawberries and pour into the prepared crust. Chill at least 2 hours to set.
3. For the cream pie: beat cream cheese with powdered sugar and vanilla until smooth. Whip the heavy cream to soft peaks and fold gently into the cream cheese mixture. Fold in chopped strawberries and lemon zest. Spoon the filling into the chilled pre-baked crust and smooth the top. Chill at least 4 hours, ideally overnight, so it firms up for clean slices.
4. To serve the glazed pie: slice with a very sharp knife dipped in warm water for clean cuts. For the cream pie: garnish with extra sliced strawberries or a light sprinkle of lemon zest.

Gather these items

• Fresh, ripe strawberries (do not use bruised fruit)
• Reliable cornstarch or thickener
• Good quality butter and vanilla
• Two 9-inch pie pans (or one pie pan and one tart pan if you prefer)

Step-by-step instructions

1. Clean and hull strawberries. Pat them dry. Divide berries between the two pies according to their preparations.
2. Make or prepare crusts: chill dough for 30 minutes if homemade. Blind-bake if your recipe calls for it.
3. Glazed pie filling: mix cornstarch slurry and cook until clear and glossy. Add lemon and butter, then toss with macerated berries.
4. Cream pie filling: beat cream cheese until smooth, incorporate powdered sugar and vanilla. Whip cream separately and fold in gently to preserve airiness.
5. Assemble each pie: pour fillings into cooled crusts. Smooth surfaces with an offset spatula.
6. Chill thoroughly: glazed pie chills for at least 2 hours; cream pie needs at least 4 hours or overnight.
7. Slice and serve cold. Use a clean, warm knife to keep slices tidy.

Best ways to enjoy it

Serve the glazed pie slightly chilled to preserve its shiny top. The cream pie is best cold and can be sliced easily for a dessert plate. For a summer dessert spread, offer both pies side by side so guests can compare texture and sweetness. Try pairing the cream pie with light coffee or a fruity iced tea and the glazed pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for contrast. If you want a lighter complement, consider a small plate of berries or the playful addition of chocolate-strawberry yogurt clusters as a sweet bite to contrast the pies.

Storage and reheating tips

• Refrigerate both pies. The glazed pie keeps well for 2 to 3 days covered loosely with plastic wrap. The cream pie will keep 3 to 4 days when tightly covered.
• Freeze: the glazed pie can be frozen for up to one month wrapped well in plastic and foil; thaw in the refrigerator overnight. The cream pie does not freeze well because whipped cream texture degrades.
• Food safety: keep pies refrigerated when not serving. Discard any pie left out at room temperature beyond 2 hours.
• Reheating: do not microwave the cream pie. If you prefer a slightly softer glazed pie filling, bring slices to room temperature for 15 minutes before serving.

Pro chef tips

• Macerate the berries for the glazed pie to draw out juices and deepen flavor, but do not over-sugar or the filling will weep.
• Cook the glaze until it just turns translucent; overcooking makes a cloudy, stiff gel.
• Chill your metal mixing bowl and beaters before whipping cream for better volume.
• If the cream pie seems loose after chilling, add a tablespoon of instant vanilla pudding powder into the cream cheese mixture next time to help stabilize it without changing the flavor.
• Handle crust as little as possible at the start to keep it flaky. Cold butter in pieces yields the best texture.

Creative twists

• Add a thin layer of lemon curd between crust and cream filling for brightness.
• Swap half the strawberries for raspberries or blueberries for a mixed berry duo.
• Make a vegan cream pie using coconut cream whipped with a touch of maple syrup and dairy-free cream cheese.
• For a nutty crust, fold finely ground almonds into the crust dough.

Your questions answered

How long does it take to make both pies?

Active prep time is about 45 to 60 minutes. Add chilling time: at least 2 hours for the glazed pie and 4 hours or overnight for the cream pie. If you plan to make one pie per day, you can spread tasks across two days.

Can I use frozen strawberries?

Yes for the glazed pie, but thaw and drain them well to remove excess water before cooking the glaze. For the cream pie, frozen strawberries will release too much liquid and make the filling watery, so use fresh if possible.

How do I prevent a runny glazed filling?

Cook the cornstarch mixture until it becomes glossy and thick. Make sure to measure cornstarch accurately and cook at a simmer until the mixture loses its raw taste and becomes translucent. Allow the glaze to cool slightly before folding in the berries to avoid breaking down the fruit too much.

Can I make the pies ahead of time?

Yes. The glazed pie holds up well when chilled and can be made a day ahead. The cream pie actually improves if made the day before, as it firms in the refrigerator and slices cleaner.

Is there a shortcut for the crust?

Store-bought crusts or pre-made graham crusts are useful time savers and work well for both pies. If you use a pre-baked crust for the cream pie, assembly is very quick.

Print